Stacey tells us about the gruesome murder of Brenda Schaefer whose break up with Mel Ignatow turned deadly when she tried to return some belongings. Erin recounts the mystery behind room 1046 and Roland T. Owen, who was a guest at the President Hotel when he died in suspicious circumstances.
Stacey discusses the murder of Reyna Marroquin whose body wasn’t discovered until 30 years after her disappearance. Erin recounts when the entire town of Circleville was blackmailed with threatening letters from an anonymous writer. Some twists, turns, and many years later, the author is still unknown and may have gotten away with murder.
Erin tells us the story of Angela Sanford, a self-proclaimed Wiccan, who invites Joel Leyva to celebrate a Wiccan holiday only to use him as a human sacrifice. Stacey shares the kidnapping and mysterious details surrounding the death of Charles Morgan of Tucson AZ who may have been involved with organized crime in the 70s.
Stacey tells us about the strange homicide of Sharon Lopatka who actively looked for a sexual partner on the internet which eventually led to her consensual death. Erin shares the mysterious deaths of David and Jeannette Crewe who were apparently murdered in their New Zealand home, but the motive has yet to be determined.
Erin tells us about the mysterious disappearance of two-year-old Pauline Picard who was later found both dead and alive. Stacey shares the torturous events that led to the eventual murder of Kelly Anne Bates at the hands of her abusive partner.
Stacey shares the story of Scott Dell a devoted family man whose obsession with his ex-wife, Cherrylle, led to his eventual murder at the hands of his beloved. Erin recounts the disappearance of 9-year-old Skyler Kauffman a young girl whose life was taken too short by an abductor just steps away from her own home.
Erin discussed the mysterious death of Anna Marie Hlavka whose murder was solved many years later thanks to DNA ancestry test kits. Stacey shares the murder of Britney Tiger, an indigenous woman whose suspicious disappearance and death remains unsolved today.
Video of Queen Mary’s Mom, Olivia Gray:
Stacey discusses the mysterious death of Joshua Maddux a teen who went missing in Woodland Park, Co and was found seven years later in an abandoned cabin a few blocks from his home. Erin tells us about Jerome Henry Brudos known as the Shoe Fetish Slayer whose obsession escalated to a violent murder spree.
Erin shares the deeds of a dirty cop Gerard Schaefer that would offer rides to hitchhikers who would mysteriously go missing. Stacey tells of the terrible day when Rex Mays snapped and in his misplaced rage murdered his two young neighbors.